header image
 

The Gisha Human Rights NGO in Israel

I am in awe of the work that the human rights NGO, Gisha, is doing in Israel. How brilliant to safeguard the  fundamental rights of Palestinians living in Gaza and the West Bank by first of all working to protect their freedom of movement. After all, how can the Palestinians have access to medical care, education, a livelihood, and the right to family unity if they do not have freedom of movement?

 It is notable that Gisha is an organization of mostly Israeli Jews who are working to protect the rights of Palestinians in a country where conflict between Jews and Palestinians is an everyday occurrence. The compassion of the Gisha members reminds me of two lines from the French writer, Edmund Fleg, “I am a Jew because in every place where suffering weeps, the Jew weeps. I am a Jew because at every time when despair cries out, the Jew hopes.”

 Given the Palestinian suicide bombers on one side, and the Israel Defense Forces on the other, it appears to the outsider that Israel and the Occupied Territories are a war zone. It takes great courage to work for the rights of Palestinians in such an area of extreme conflict. Aside from the intentional killing that goes on in a war zone, other dangers are present. The Prussian soldier and military theorist, Carl Von Clausewitz, coined the term “Fog of War” to explain: “how confused warfare can seem while one is immersed within it.” (Wikipedia) Out of this confusion come mistakes and accidents.

 As an example, in 2003 an American peace activist, 23 year-old Rachel Corrie (See the bulldozer) was killed when an Israeli military bulldozer ran over her. Witnesses to the incident claim that the bulldozer driver intentionally ran over and killed her. The Israeli government says that the driver of the bulldozer did not see or hear her and that it was an accident.

 The work of Gisha in Israel also reminds me of a non-violent resistance group in Nazi Germany known as the White Rose.  The core members of the White Rose were a philosophy professor and six of his students, all in their early twenties. The White Rose group wrote and distributed leaflets calling for active opposition by the German people to the oppression of Hitler and the Nazis. The best remembered of the students are Sophie Scholl (See the Nazis interrogate Sophie.) and her brother Hans. The members of the White Rose group were caught by the Gestapo and decapitated under the blade of a guillotine in 1943.

What is the answer to bring lasting peace to Israelis and Palestinians? Perhaps it will be the two-state proposal being advanced by President Barack Obama and others. Ultimately however, peace will have to come from the hearts of Palestinians and Israelis. Peace cannot come too soon to this area. Israelis and Palestinians have suffered enough. “If you want to make peace with your enemy, you have to work with your enemy. Then he becomes your partner.” Antoine de Saint Exupery

 

Category:  Israel/Palestine     

On the Edge of the Universe

 Why did three of the world’s major religions originate in the Middle East? For the answer to this question, I invite you to a sanctuary deliciously devoid of the trappings of our time. One caveat - we must first pass through more of the chaos and clamor that inundates our biggest cities.

 We take a plane to Cairo, Egypt, a cauldron of some 20 million souls locked in a struggle to secure enough calories for the day and keep a roof over their heads. From there, a van shuttles us north through the lush delta of the Nile, its peasants following the agricultural rhythms laid down in the time of the pharaohs.

 Breaking out of the heat and dust, we cruise through the gentle sea breezes of Alexandria, once home to a vibrant community of artists, writers, and long departed Jews, Armenians, and Greeks who fled Egypt after Nasser grabbed the reins of power in 1952.

 Tacking west along the Mediterranean, we pass El Alamein, site of a graveyard hosting over 8,000 souls who perished in the Western Desert campaigns of World War II. Then, just after the turquoise waters of Marsa Matruh, we head south into the sahara, Arabic for desert.

 Our destination is the Siwa Oasis lying only 30 miles from the Libyan border.  An outlier of some 25,000 ethnic Berbers, Siwa is separated from the rest of Egypt by the Western Desert and was only connected to the outside world by asphalt road as recently as 1984. After one night in Siwa we focus on the goal of our trip to this outpost of civilization: the Great Sand Sea. (photo, good enough to eat)

 Home to no one, the Great Sand Sea is a seamless mass of sand, smothering the desolate frontiers of Libya and Egypt. Its parallel dunes begin just three kilometers out of Siwa and spill south for almost 800 kilometers to the bottom of Egypt where they run smack into the Gilf Kebir. (See the dunes meet the Gilf), a limestone/sandstone plateau the size of Switzerland and rising 1,000 feet above the desert floor.

The dunes of the Great Sand Sea are relentlessly driven by the Hamseen, cousin to the other winds of the Arab and Persian worlds: Haboob; Harmattan; Simoom; Shamal; Sharki; and Sirocco. Following their geological imperative, the billions and billions of sand grains that make up these dunes climb higher and higher on the shoulders of their neighbors drowning everything in their wake.  At the Gilf Kebir, the dunes have accomplished the unthinkable, breaching its 1,000 foot-high crest.

 Cassandra Vivian, author of The Western Desert of Egypt: An Explorer’s Handbook, has written, “When all life forms have disappeared from the continents, only the sand dunes will remain.” Her advice: “Anyone planning an expedition to the dunes of the Great Sand Sea has to be especially well prepared, as there’s not a single water source in 150,000 square miles.”

 At the Gilf Kebir, nature parsimoniously bestows only a few centimeters of rain once every 13 years. Just west over the border, the Libyan Desert, the most arid region on Earth, is the site of the highest recorded temperature – a startling 58 degrees C (136 F) recorded south of Tripoli in September 1922.

 Having secured two jeeps, each with a driver and guide, our party heads out. Once clear of town, we stop and our guide deflates the tires to 15 psi to help the vehicle float on the deep sand. We approach the first dune and the driver expertly snakes his way up: steady gas, no sudden starts or stops, keep the jeep moving. (Seatbelt fastened!)

 When we hit the crest the view is breathtaking: endless dunes soft and sinuous under an impeccable cerulean sky. And something surprising about the air – such a light, fresh, clean fragrance with overtones of salt as if we are at the ocean. However, the most overwhelming element is the silence – deep, absolute and all encompassing. No other place, yet experienced, is bathed in this exquisite silence that seems to shout a mysterious presence.

 For a few hours we continue cresting the dunes and fording the tight valleys that lie between them. By now the sun is high overhead burning the sand and we are as parched as the dunes themselves. About ten kilometers into the dunes we stop and make camp. The afternoon sun and heat have been brutal and a question is nagging in the back of the head. What is it about the desert that kept inviting the prophets and holy people of the Middle East to seek it out? Were they intent on inflicting deprivation and hardship on themselves, or was there something more?

 The guides make a small campfire out of the stump of an olive tree that they have lashed to the Jeep. Soon a delicious stew of chicken and vegetables is ready. One guide sits on a half empty water jug and taps out different Arab and Berber rhythms – an Elvin Jones of the desert. Night falls, the fire turns to embers and you feel something calling you away from the camp.

 Spent from the days adventure, you trudge to the crest of the nearest dune where you squat with your knees under your chin. As you perch on the edge of the universe, a panorama of ineffable beauty thrills you: the heavens are lit with billions and billions of stars, big as bushel baskets. The overpowering silence along with a mysterious presence, now intense and palpable, penetrates you to the core. You reach out your hand and touch the face of God. 

 Bibliography: Vivian, Cassandra, The Western Desert of Egypt: An Explorer’s Handbook

 A special thanks to our guides, Mostafa and Ahmed for their laughter, music, and for taking us safely to the edge of the universe.

 Mr. Guthrie

 

 

Category:  Uncategorized